
A recent analysis of the 2026 Big Survey’s Performance data reveals that midsize independent businesses, or indies, are more likely to have a higher net profit margin. Among indies that track their net profit margin, 47% of those with $250,001 to $1 million in 2025 sales reported a net profit margin of 11% or more.
This is compared to 29% of indies with more than $1 million in 2025 sales and 20% of indies with less than $250,000 in 2025 sales. The analysis suggests that midsize indies may have outgrown the thin margins of the smallest stores without taking on the payroll and rent of the biggest.
Profit Margins and Sales
Losing money or breaking even is most common at the smallest indies, with 46% of indies with less than $250,000 in 2025 sales reporting a loss or breaking even in 2025. In contrast, 19% of indies with more than $1 million in 2025 sales and 16% of indies with $250,001 to $1 million in 2025 sales reported a loss or breaking even.
The data also shows that bigger indies tend to have bigger baskets, with an average sale of more than $60 being most common at the largest indies.
Growth Expectations
Among owners, expecting 2026 sales to rise tracks with how aggressively they are growing. 89% of owners building or growing aggressively said they expect 2026 sales to rise, compared to 41% of owners growing selectively and 16% of owners maintaining what they have built.
Expecting a higher 2026 net profit margin follows the same pattern, with 53% of owners building or growing aggressively saying they expect their 2026 net profit margin to rise. This suggests that mindset and outlook may feed each other, with owners focused on growth investing in what they expect to pay off, and those investments lifting the outlook.
Private label indies also see fewer challenges, with 32% of indies who don’t private label saying they expect 2026 sales to fall, compared to 20% of indies who private label. Expecting a higher 2026 net profit margin is more common among indies who private label, with 23% saying they expect their 2026 net profit margin to rise, compared to 13% of indies who don’t private label.
AI Usage and Profit Margins
Indies who use AI also expect better margins, with 22% of AI users saying they expect their 2026 net profit margin to rise, compared to 10% of non-AI users. Not tracking net profit margin is more common among indies who don’t use AI, with 27% saying they don’t track their net profit margin, compared to 16% of AI users.
